| Nathaniel BUTLER (1761 - 1829) |
Gilbert James LIVINGSTON |
| Sarah HERRICK (1764 - 1823) |
Susanna LEWIS |
| Samuel Herrick BUTLER | Judith LIVINGSTON |
| bd. 12 Feb 1785, Bennington, VT occ. edu. rel. dd. 13 Dec 1851, Columbus, OH, Age: 66 brd. ali. chd. |
bd. 4 Sep 1785, Poughkeepsie, NY occ. edu. rel. dd. 28 Feb 1858, Columbus, OH, Age: 72 brd. ali. chd. |
| Courtland Philip Livingston BUTLER |